American-Atheists

Does Court Ruling Open Schools to Creation Science?

avatar
Print Friendly and PDF

By Charlie Butts

Atheists may have opened themselves up for a challenge as a result of a lawsuit decided in Kentucky. 

OneNewsNow –Atheist group American Atheists filed suit in Kentucky federal court claiming that giving religious groups and pastors tax exemptions discriminates against atheists.

The court disagreed, ruling that atheists can’t claim discrimination because they had not applied and been rejected for the same benefits.

Attorney Harry Mihet of Liberty Counsel explains that the legal test for a religious or nonreligious organization does not involve believing in a deity.Mihet, Harry (Liberty Counsel)

“So interestingly enough,” he says, “the court is suggesting that the atheists can receive the same types of benefits because they themselves are a religion or religious.”

Mihet calls that a “remarkable concept,” one Liberty Counsel has been pursuing in the courts for some time because it has important implications.

Why? Because subjects such as evolution are allowed to be taught in schools but creation science is denied.

Mihet explains: “Because if atheism or humanism are religions themselves, and public schools decide to teach the tenets of those religions while excluding the tenets of other theistic religions, then that is discriminatory treatment in and of itself.”

So the Liberty Counsel attorney contends that in claiming discrimination, the atheists may have opened the door for challenges from Christians and other faith groups in the future.

On its own website, the atheist group reported it filed suit in 2012, complaining that secular non-profits do not submit the same IRS filings and report the same information as religious non-profits.

In 2012 the U.S. government filed a motion to dismiss, arguing the tax laws don’t harm the group. The federal judge ruled in favor of the government’s motion to dismiss May 19.

Report via OneNewsNow

Print Friendly and PDF



Posting Policy

We have no tolerance for comments containing violence, racism, vulgarity, profanity, all caps, or discourteous behavior. Thank you for partnering with us to maintain a courteous and useful public environment where we can engage in reasonable discourse. Read More

  • HarryVB

    There’s no such thing as creation science, so this article is pointless. “Creation science” is an oxymoron.

  • QuestionsEverything

    When will people learn that atheism is not a religion, and that evolution is not a tenet of atheism?

  • The Skeptical Chymist

    Evolution is a scientific theory. It is no more a tenet of atheism than Newton’s laws of motion are a tenet of Christianity.

  • basegitar

    Headline should read: Some guy named Butts thinks the Earth is 6,000 years old!

  • Persephone Sixty-Six

    Evolution is not a tenet of atheism. Evolution is science and atheism has no tenets.

    Creation science is not science, it’s believing that “The Flintstones” was a documentary.

  • IntelligenceisAVirtue

    You can put Creationism in a science class as soon as there is some actual science to back it up.

EmailTitle2

Sign up for BarbWire alerts!